| 2023 | Huntginton Beach (Calif.) | JSerra Catholic (Calif.) |
| 2022 | Stoneman Douglas (Fla.) | St. Johns Country Day (Fla.) |
| 2019 | Orange Lutheran (Calif.) | Harvard-Westlake (Calif.) |
| 2018 | Orange Lutheran (Calif.) | Green Hope (N.C.) |
| 2017 | Orange Lutheran (Calif.) | Dana Hills (Calif.) |
| 2016 | Huntington Beach (Calif.) | Chaminade Prep (Calif.) |
| 2015 | San Clemente (Calif.) | College Park (Calif.) |
| 2014 | The First Academy (Fla.) | Clovis (Calif.) |
| 2013 | Mater Dei (Calif.) | Harvard-Westlake (Calif.) |
| 2012 | Mater Dei (Calif.) | Haravard-Westlake (Calif.) |
